ADOBE INDESIGN WINDOWS 66 RE IS INDESIGN THE RIGHT PRODUCT FOR OUR NEEDS
From: Ken_Grace@no-spam
Subject: Re: Is InDesign the right product for our needs?
Date: Mon, 5 Apr 2004 09:04:38 -0700


Thanks Bob. Sites like frighten me - you think you know a bit about something and they show you know diddly squat.

In a magazine environment when illustrations and advertisements are coming from all directions I have found that the most problems arise when ads or illustrations have embedded colour profiles. I have always understood that colour profiles adjust colour rendering to compensate for dot gain, paper,
ink chemistry and other printing characteristics, and that unless you know how a job is to be printed, applying a colour profile could do more harm than good.

One company that regularly sends me press releases has a standard rider to the releases that specifies the CMYK and RAL colour for its machine paintwork, and demands that I ensure that the machine picture is printed in those colours ! The machine is light blue, and the requirement is 'not to print in green'. Opening the files in some graphics viewer type programs does, in fact, show the machine as dark green. The pictures have an embedded colour profile and I have assumed that this is being read and interpreted by some programs in a way that distorts the colour to this unacceptable level,
and that not to have embedded a colour profile would be safer than doing so.

Am I confusing profiles used, as you say, to balance colour from different creation devices with profiles intended to compensate for printing distortions?

k